MDCTC Transition response
Local Government Finance Policy Welsh Government Cathays Park Cardiff CF10 3NQ
3rd November 2016
Re: Response to proposed arrangements to provide transitional relief to support small businesses adversely affected by the 2017 non-domestic rates revaluation
Despite the revaluation exercise only being completed on 30th September businesses and other organisations have been asked to comment by 4th November on the transitional arrangements, which will benefit those previously or post April 2017, as being eligible for Small Business Rate Relief. We regard this six-week consultation period as a ridiculously short time scale for the consultation and it is likely therefore to make the result unbalanced.
As initial future instigators of these transitional arrangements and final recipients of business rates income, we believe that the Welsh Government had a duty to inform the businesses of Wales and those organisations representing those businesses, not only about these transitional arrangements, but also about the results of the business rateable value revaluation. This the Welsh Government has singularly failed to do. Instead it has relied on the media to raise awareness of both exercises. Not only was our Chamber unaware of the results of the revaluation and of the proposed transitional arrangements, but so were South, Mid and West Wales Chambers of Commerce. We find this unacceptable when the Welsh economy is dependent on 96.4% of businesses, which are micro businesses (9 employees or less) and where business rates represent a significant part of their operating costs.
Transitional arrangements may seem in concept to be a good idea, but it is only designed to assist those businesses who were, are and will be, entitled to Small Business Rate Relief (SBBR). It is evident from research on the www.tax.service.gov.uk website that we in Monmouth have many small retailers who were slightly above the £12000 SBRR limit and now face average 50% increases in their business rateable value. The highest identified so far at 137%! This would suggest that the SBBR limit should be raised for 2017/18, perhaps to £20,000 or £25,000. The Welsh Government’s delay in examining Small Business Rate Relief until 2018 is again unacceptable, as proposed rate increases will happen next year.
Businesses are seemingly denied a route to make representations about proposed changes to their business rates other than through the appeal process, which begins in April 2017. This too we find unacceptable.
Monmouthshire is the county most affected by business rateable value revaluations with increases in the retail (11%), Offices (10.5%) and Other (13.5%). This may indicate that the valuation process adopted for the county was seriously flawed. The Welsh Government consultation document clearly states that there will be winners and losers from this revaluation exercise. Most small businesses in Monmouthshire will be losers and, as the overall take of the Welsh government from business rates is supposed to be the same after the revaluation, it means the businesses of Monmouthshire are in effect subsidising businesses elsewhere.
We believe that the results of the revaluation for Monmouthshire are so at odds with the other unitary authorities in Wales, as to be worthy or more investigation and special treatment. We propose two options to resolve this major threat to the viability of small businesses in our county, as follows:
The valuation is set aside and the exercise undertaken again. We consider this unlikely as there are 3167 businesses with premises in the county, or
All businesses whose rateable value has increased by more than the county average to have their appeal heard ASAP and not have to wait until April 2017
We are happy for our comments and contact details to be displayed in full on the VO website
David Cummings FIAB
Chairman, Monmouth and District Chamber of Trade and Commerce
Business rateable value revaluation - the emerging picture
31st October 2016
There has been a great deal of local and national press coverage on the very adverse effects the increases proposed for 2O17/18 will have on small businesses. In Wales we are a country of small business with 96.4% of businesses being designated as micro i.e 9 employees or less. Particularly hard hit with business rate increase proposals are small retailers
The Valuation Office (VOA) in their report say there will be winners and losers and that the overall take from business rates will not increase. Nearly all counties of Wales have seen rateable values in the retail sector fall for 2017/18. Only Conwy with 4.7% increase and Monmouthshire with 11% average increase have seen material increases as a result of this VOA exercise.
Looking more specifically on a local basis, it is evident that small retail businesses in Monmouth have seen dramatic increases in the rates they will need to pay in 2017/18. I have conducted research on-line on the VOA site of 25 small retailers and the average increase in percentage terms of rateable value is 50% and the highest a huge 137%. New rateable values should broadly equate to rental values in April 2015. There is evidence that some rental values have actually decreased, not risen dramatically. If the Welsh Government had tested the effect on a sample basis of businesses this would have highlighted the anomalies in the revaluation.
Over the last week Monmouth Chamber has been in contact with officers responsible for business development at Monmouthshire County Council. Informatian we have provided has ensured that the subject of business rateable value revaluations has now been given top priority and I am confident that will play their part to secure a more equitable result.
Despite the revaluation exercise only being completed on 30th September businesses have been asked to comment by 4th November on the transitional arrangements, which will benefit those previously or post 30th September as being eligible for Small Business Rate Relief. lt would seem that the Welsh government have decided to conducf this consultation in a passive way, i.e they have not contacted organisations representing businesses such as Chambers of Commerce . We regard this approach as highly regrettable and WG inertia as unsatisfactory. Monmouth Chamber will be making representations by 4th November deadline mentioning, amongst other matters, the ridiculously short time scale for the consultation and the lack of contact with key stakeholders.
Transitional arrangements may seem in concept to be a good idea, but is only designed to assist those businesses who were entitled to Small Business Rate Relief SBRR in 2016/17. lt is evident from research on the VOA website that we have many small retailers who were slightly above the £12000 SBRR limit and now face 50% increases in their business rateable value. This would suggest that the SBRR limit should have been raised far 2017/18, perhaps to £20,000 or £25,000.
The Chamber considers that the Welsh Govemment should have looked at the revaluation figures and anticipated this crisis, especially for the counties of Monmouthshire and Conwy. Rest assured that the Chamber will continue to liase with MCC and take the matter further with Assembly Ministers and in particularly Ken Skates, Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Infrastructure.
I am in communication with a chartered surveyor from the Welsh Ratepayers Forum , which is a body recognised by the Welsh government to make representations on business rate issues, to come to present on this matter at our Chamber meeting on 21st November. NonChamber members are welcome to attend the Chamber meeting, but must book with me first by email to email@example.com by 14tn November. Further details of the meeting can be found at www.mdctc.co.uk.
Chairman, Monmouth and District Chamber of Trade and Commerce